10 Best Burgundy Eyeliners (Products & Guide)

burgundy eyeliners

Sharing is caring!

Burgundy eyeliner is not typically someone’s first color of choice. If done poorly, it can make your eyes look bloodshot or tired instead of delivering the unexpected pop of color that you want. 

So what is the best burgundy eyeliner out there? And how do you achieve the best burgundy eye? I am sharing with you a few of my favorite burgundy eyeliners and a couple of tips and tricks to create those dashing burgundy highlights. 

best burgundy eyeliners guide and reviews text overlay

This post may contain affiliate links. That means if you click and buy, I may receive a small commission (at zero cost to you). Please see my full disclosure policy for details.

#1 Best Burgundy Eyeliner Overall

It is undeniable that some eyeliners are better than others, and the one that rises to the very top of my list is the Urban Decay Glide-on Eyeliner. Here’s why I love it:

1. Urban Decay Glide-On Eyeliner

Price: $20-$25 Check the current price here.

Best Features:

Waterproof: I love waterproof liners, and believe they are an essential quality to a good eyeliner. This particular eyeliner works so well because it is specifically designed to go on the waterline without smearing or smudging.

Healthy Ingredients: Urban Decay’s eyeliner contains a few great ingredients that are worth noting. In this pencil, you will find jojoba and cottonseed oil, which both soften the skin and Vitamin E which hydrates the skin. 

Best Burgundy Eyeliner: Pencils

Eyeliner pencils are some of the easiest eyeliners for beginners to use and are usually the least messy of the three options. If you are just starting to play with eyeliner looks, or you can’t resist a classic pencil, check out a few of my favorites below.

2. Shiseido MicoLiner Link Eyeliner

Price: $20-$25 Check current price here.

Best Features: 

Matte Finish: Shiseido’s eyeliner leaves your eyes with a gorgeous matte finish that stays on your face for a full 24 hours. 

Thermo-Sensory Technology: One of the reasons I love this pencil is because of how high-tech it is. It is designed with thermo-sensory technology that transforms the solid pencil into a liquid form upon contact with the skin. 

Micro-thin tip: The tip on this pencil is unbelievably thin. It was created to mimic the Sumi ink pens used in Japanese technology, so its precision is unbeatable! 

Master Makeup Program – Online

Transform your passion into expertise with the Master Makeup Program: from makeup fundamentals to advanced professional techniques, includes digital guides, a PROFESSIONAL BOOK delivered to your home, and a CERTIFICATE of completion PLUS bonuses– all in one online self-paced program!
More than $480 value, regular price $97
now only $67!

3. HAUS Eye-dentify Eye Pencil

Price: Pretty reasonable priced, more on the affordable side. Check best the offer here

Best Features: 

Bold color: Lady Gaga is known for her daring and bright looks, so it is no wonder that her eyeliner line offers a vast array of bold and daring colors. I love the burgundy shade of this eyeliner because of its rich, highly pigmented formula.

Sharpenable: Some pencils do not like to be sharpened and will break or become less precise if sharpened, but this pencil is easy to sharpen and stays precise! 

No-Slip Formula: Even though this is a pencil, it is made with an extra-creamy formula to create a no-slip, one-swipe application process. No skips for this eyeliner!

4. NYX Faux Black Eyeliner Pencil

Price: Cheap! Drugstore price. Check the price here.

Best Features:
Subtle Color: If you aren’t quite ready for a bright burgundy eyeliner, this pencil is for you.

This NYX line is specifically designed to create subtle colors while still looking professional, and this burgundy creates a more muted look.

Cruelty-Free: All NYX products are cruelty-free, and this pencil is also made with a vegan formula!

Smooth Application: Another great feature of this pencil is that it is creamy, and goes on smooth and precise, without creating any skips or stops. 

5. L’Oreal Infallible Pro-Last Pencil

Price: On the cheaper side. Affordable. Check the current price here.

Best Features:

No-Budge Formula: One great quality of this eyeliner is that it stays in place all day long. It promises 24-hour wear without smearing, smudging, or fading. No need to worry about touching up your eyeliner throughout the day, L’Oreal’s pencil isn’t going anywhere!

Water-Resistant: This eyeliner is also made to withstand the elements. It is water-resistant and sweat-resistant, so come what may, this eyeliner is staying with you.

Sharpenable: This is another pencil that is easy to sharpen. Many customers recommend ditching an eyeliner sharpener with this pencil, and instead, use an old-school metal sharpener for the best results. 

6. Milani Stay Put Eyeliner

Price: Pretty Affordable. Drugstore price. Check here the price.

Best Features:

Stays in Place: As you can imagine by the name, this eyeliner is notorious for staying in one place. It is waterproof and sweatproof, so there is nothing that can stand in the way of bold eyes. 

Built-in Sharpener: Milani’s pencil also comes with a built-in sharpener. All you have to do is twist clockwise to draw the pencil out, and Milani does the hard work for you by keeping this pencil sharp and precise use after use.

Rich-Pigment: This burgundy is bold, and will leave your eyes with an unbelievably bright pop of color. Plus, you can apply this eyeliner in just one stroke, no need to layer on this liner to create bold color.

7. CLIO Sharp So Simple Pencil

Price: Affordable. Check best price.

Best Features:

Self-Sharpening Tip: This pencil is also designed with a self-sharpening tip, so no need to worry about breaking the tip or dulling it with a sharpener. This tip is also extremely thin, so it is easy to create precise lines.

Waterproof: CLIO’s pencil is also waterproof and sweatproof, so it does not flake, fade, smudge, or smear throughout the day. 

Glides-On: Another great feature of this pencil is that it is easy to use. Its creamy formula makes for a one-swipe experience without tugging, pulling, or skipping. It just glides on with no struggle at all. 

Best burgundy eyeliner: liquids

Pencils can’t have all the fun, right? Liquid eyeliners are great if you have a steady hand and want an extra bold and bright pop of color on your eyes. Here are a few of my favorites.

8. Revlon ColorStay Liquid Eyeliner

Price: Affordable. Check the price here.

Best Features:

Precise Tip: Sometimes liquid eyeliner can be intimidating to wear if you aren’t a master at eyeliner yet. But this liquid eyeliner comes with an ultra-fine tip (only 0.1 millimeters) to make applying your eyeliner easy.

Long-Lasting: This eyeliner has a guaranteed 10 hour long wear, and customers love that it stays on all day without any smudging or smearing. Plus, it goes on without any skips or slips!

Create thicker lashes: You can also dot this makeup in between your lashes to create the illusion of thicker, bolder eyelashes. 

9. Forencos Tattoo Liquid Eyeliner

Price: Drugstore price. Affordable. Check the price here.

Best Features:

Natural Ingredients: Forencos engineered this eyeliner with a black seed complex, which works perfectly to moisturize and hydrate your eyes.

Doesn’t dry out: Another awesome feature of this eyeliner is that it is made with ink tank technology, so this liner will not dry out. 

No Smudging: This eyeliner is extremely smudge-proof. Even if you accidentally rub your eyes, this liner will stay on firmly. Additionally, it is waterproof and oil-proof, so it can withstand the elements of day-to-day life. 

Best burgundy eyeliner: gel

Last, but certainly not least are a couple of my favorite gel liners!

10. Colourpop Creme Gel Color

Price: Cheap. Check the price here.

Best Features:

Deep Pigment: One of the best features of this liner is that it is highly pigmented. This burgundy liner will definitely make your eyes pop!

Matte Finish: This gel eyeliner leaves a beautiful matte finish on your eyes, which pairs well with any neutral matte eyeshadow.

Long-Lasting: Many customers say that this gel liner lasted for at least 8 hours, but for many, it lasted even longer!

11. Melt Ultra Matte Gel Eyeliner

Price: Not a drugstore price. Still pretty reasonable. Check the price here.

Best Features:

Matte-Finish: As mentioned in the name, this gel liner creates a gorgeous matte finish and locks your liner in place all day long.

Waterproof: Melt’s eyeliner is also waterproof and sweatproof, so it will stay on your eyes all day without smearing or smudging.

Vegan: Finally, this gel liner is vegan, cruelty-free, and gluten-free. And if that wasn’t enough, this product is also paraben-free, so you don’t have to put any nasty chemicals near your eyes.

How do you apply burgundy eyeliner?

There are a few ways to ensure that your burgundy eyeliner looks top-notch.

  • Wear mascara: One of the keys to making sure that burgundy eyeliner does not make your eyes look bloodshot is by wearing a dark mascara to balance out the red in the eyeliner. 
  • Don’t apply to the waterline: Burgundy eyeliner looks great just about anywhere, but applying on the waterline can risk looking extra tired. Opt for a bold look on the lid instead. 
  • Keep makeup neutral: With burgundy eyeliner, you don’t want to add too many other colors into the mix, so try picking a soft pink or nude look for the rest of your face to make sure your bright eyeliner gets all the attention. 

Check this post: My Secret Eyeliner tips to STOP eyeliner from smudging (on upper and bottom lid)

Is burgundy eyeliner good for blue eyes?

While some people worry that burgundy eyeliner might not work for blue eyes, the truth is, burgundy eyeliner can work well on any eye color. It can actually make a beautiful contrast with the blue of the eyes!

Conclusion on best burgundy eyeliners

Our #1 best recommendation for Burgundy eyeliner is this one here. It’s a high-quality waterproof eyeliner that lasts all day! But still have this perfect smooth formula to work with it while it is still wet. Once it dries, it won’t smudge!

Burgundy eyeliner is not as scary as it might seem initially. While there are definitely some ways to make it look better on your eyes, this color will look good with any eye, no matter the eye color.

I hope that you found a pencil, liquid eyeliner, or gel eyeliner that works for you so you can head into the fall season with eyes that match!

What’s Next? Related Eyeliner Posts:

10 Best Burgundy Eyeliners (Products + Guide)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Real Beauty School